Your good decisions feel like mistakes halfway through


Two quick things before this week’s newsletter:

Tomorrow (Friday 20th November, 12:30–1pm GMT), Katie da Gama and I are doing a free LinkedIn Live on why so many new partners in professional services firm feel they have to fake it. You can register here.

I’ve also applied to speak at SXSW London next year, with a talk called “The Boss Lottery: Why It’s About to Matter More Than Ever”. Voting closes on Sunday, and you can vote for it here. If you enjoy my newsletters, voting is a great way to support me. I’d really appreciate it.

——

A friend of mine recently got a puppy.

They live in a flat with no garden, which makes toilet training tricky, and there are no relatives nearby to help look after the dog. They've also lost some of the freedom they used to take for granted.

It's changed their life so much that they're now thinking of leaving the flat and moving to a different part of the country.

Pretty much everyone I know who's had a dog went through a version of this. Things were good before the dog, then there was the excitement of something new, then it got messy, then it got a bit easier, and eventually it was better than before. And now they love it.

My friend is in the messy middle right now.

When things were already good

I had my own version of this when I left KPMG to start my business.

I'd had a pretty successful career there, and I wanted to build something of my own. But I'd given up a safe, well-paid job, and starting from scratch was hard.

The first nine months felt like the messy middle. It was only towards the end of the first year that things started to look like they were going to be sustainable.

The messy middle is hard for anyone. But I think it's harder when things were good to begin with.

You can remember exactly what life was like before. So as well as being hard, the messy middle starts to feel like a mistake, especially after all the excitement.

And you probably hadn't appreciated how good life was until something new took a bit of it away.

The more senior you get, the more of your changes start from a strong base.

You go for the bigger role because the current one is going well. You hire someone senior into a team that's already working, because you can see how much better it could be. And you replace a system that was doing the job, because you want more from it.

These are good things to do. They build on something strong, and they come from wanting to make it even better.

When things are going well, staying where you are is very tempting. The more you have to protect, the less appealing a few months of mess becomes. But I'm not sure you get to better than before any other way.

When you're three months into a bigger role and working longer hours than ever, it's easy to look back at the old one and wonder why you left it.

So the messy middle will feel like a mistake far more often than it actually is one.

Your team is a few weeks behind you

It gets more complicated when the change you've made lands on your team.

By the time you announce the new hire or the new system, you've usually been living with the idea for some time. You've had the excitement, you've probably had some doubts, and you've worked through them.

Your team hears about it on the day you announce it, and goes straight into the messy middle.

So just as you're starting to feel good about it, they're at the worst of it. I think some of what sounds like resistance is just people in the messy middle.

And once you're through it yourself, it's easy to forget how bad it was. (I suspect that's how people end up with a second dog.)

So when you hand your team the next change, it’s easy to underestimate how hard it will be for them.

My friend is still in it, and I don't know yet whether they'll move. But if they're like pretty much everyone else I know who's had a dog, they'll end up loving it.

Are you in the middle of anything right now that feels like it might have been a mistake?

Chances are, you’re just in the messy middle.

And who’s in it with you?

Thanks for reading.

Mostyn

P.S. The first year (or two!) as a partner is its own messy middle. The title suggests you’ve arrived, while the job asks you to do lots of things for the first time. If you’re a new partner, or you support them, Katie da Gama and I are talking about it in a free 30-minute LinkedIn Live tomorrow at 12:30pm GMT. Register here.

P.P.S. A last reminder about SXSW London. My talk, “The Boss Lottery”, is about how much your experience of work depends on who you happen to work for, and why that’s about to matter more than ever. Voting closes on Sunday. You can vote for it here. Huge thanks!


Next
Next

Your team said yes before they knew the cost